Why Success Still Feels Empty
Why can success still leave you feeling unfulfilled? In this thought-provoking conversation, Divya Parekh and John R. Miles explore The Great Erasure—the way achievement and productivity can become tied to identity and self-worth. They discuss mattering at work, the hidden cost of constantly proving your value, and John’s M.A.T.T.E.R. framework from his forthcoming book, The Mattering Effect. The episode asks: where does your sense of worth come from beyond achievement?
Beyond Confidence is broadcast live Tuesdays at 10AM ET on W4WN Radio - Women 4 Women Network (www.w4wn.com) part of Talk 4 Radio (www.talk4radio.com) on the Talk 4 Media Network (www.talk4media.com). Beyond Confidence TV Show is viewed on Talk 4 TV (www.talk4tv.com).
Beyond Confidence Podcast is also available on Talk 4 Media (www.talk4media.com), Talk 4 Podcasting (www.talk4podcasting.com), iHeartRadio, Amazon Music, Pandora, Spotify, Audible, and over 100 other podcast outlets.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/beyond-confidence--1885197/support.
0:00 This is Beyond Confidence with your host, Divya Parikh. Do you want to live a more fulfilling life? Do you want to live your legacy and achieve your personal, professional, and financial goals? Well, coming up on Divya Parikh's Beyond Confidence, you will hear real stories of leaders, entrepreneurs, and achievers who have stepped into discomfort, shattered their status quo, and are living the life they want. You will learn how relationships are the key to achieving your aspirations and financial goals. Moving your career or business forward does not have to happen at the expense of your personal or family life, or vice versa. Learn more at www.diviapark.com, and you can connect with Divya at contact at divyapark.com. This is Beyond Confidence, and now here's your host, Divya Park.
0:46 Good morning, listeners. It's Tuesday morning, and we are thrilled to be here. And the key is that hiccups happen in life. So just today, sometimes misunderstandings happen, and especially with the digital age, we need so many different links and connections to connect. But the key is having. The kindness in heart and being open and having that flexibility to dance with uncertainty because life happens. And when life happens, it's completely fantastic, like, To go about it is the key to just dance with it and work your way through it in the best way you can.
1:35 So I'm sure that you all are hearing a lot about artificial intelligence. We are hearing a lot. Of doomsday calls and a lot of uncertainties in the air. So the key is that how do you go about it, whether you're bringing in AI, whether it is for your own business or or in your personal life, or in your organization. The key is putting the guardrails, having that governance. And exactly how do you bring it in safely? That's what our book talks about, the AI agency. So if you're looking to bring it in in a safe way, if you're looking to bring it in so that it creates the space for you, where you can be creative, where you can be doing meaningful work, we can coexist together with Human in the Loop. So if you're looking for it, so please get a book because we share part of the proceeds with kiva.org. And we want to thank you to each and every one of you who have got our books and been part of our journey together.
2:48 So today we will be talking about a little bit about a. Lot of different things. And we have a very special guest for you. So let's welcome our guest. Welcome, John. Divya, it's so great to be here. Thank you so much for the honor of being on your show. Oh, it's lovely to have you. So John, do you recall. A moment in your life or a person who have left a positive mark on you that you remember to this day? Yeah. A great person, um, who was very influential very early in my life was my speech therapist. When I was five and a half, um, I had a really bad accident, uh, playing in my backyard where I was pushed from behind and, uh, the force carried me through our basement window. And, uh, I awoke some point later with a traumatic brain injury.
3:53 And as a result of that, I developed a speech impediment, sensory processing disorder, migraines, a whole bunch of other things. But, uh, My speech problems were one of the most impactful because they influenced so many things when I was a kid and how I spoke to others, obviously. And long before I ever learned what neuroplasticity was, she really taught me that we had a choice in life. We could either accept things our circumstances and do something positive with them, or we could be a victim and that framing. And she did it in a way that a five-year-old could understand it completely changed for me that the trajectory of how I approached life from that point forward.
4:54 Oh, you are so young and to have, it must have just alarming and, you know, being a child and just, I know it has turned out well for you. I just hope nobody has to go through because parents, it can be such a nightmare. So sounds like it definitely left a lot of positive impact on you and you learn to make good choices. So if you're okay sharing, how long did it last as far as the effects of that brain injury and how long did it take you to get back to your normal vocabulary and normal communication?
5:39 Well, I'm not sure it's ever been fully back to what it was before. It would be to actually know that for sure. And then when I was in the military in combat, I had a few more traumatic brain injuries, which brought many of the symptoms back So it's something I've learned to cope with my entire life. And luckily, because I've done a lot of public speaking and participated in improv classes and Toastmasters and other things, I do my best to this day to overcome the challenges. But there's still times when they pop up, sometimes in the worst moments. But it's definitely, I think when you have a disability, especially one where you look completely fine on the outside, but inside you're living with it, those invisible disabilities sometimes make it harder to exist in the world around us.
6:49 Yeah, and kudos to you. First of all, I want to thank you for your service because we do not recognize our heroes and sheroes enough for. All those sacrifices. And thank you. Just a heartfelt thank you for your services, John. And I could not have said anything otherwise. And as you said, you know, it can leave a mark within. And we started out today with a small crisis, just trying to figure things out. And this is such a such a big crisis.
7:30 In your life, and you mentioned that you're working through it, and you have built meaning and worth around it. So tell us that as you grew, did you naturally gravitate towards the military, or how did your career unfold? Divya, I had spent more than a decade trying to recover from that event when I was young. And I had learned to overcome those disabilities as best as I possibly could and had become a good student, a good athlete by the time I was in high school. But I want to share with you what the damage a negative influence can do on your life. since I shared a positive one. Somewhere around my junior year in high school, I was trying to decide my life path. And my life path at that time was most likely going to be to go to a normal university. I had gotten into a number of them. My entire family all attended the University of Michigan. So when I got a scholarship there, That was really the path that I had always thought
9:01 I would go on. That said, my grandfather served in World War II and my father served in the Marine Corps as well. So the calling to serve our country was also something that was always a foundation in my life. But the moment that I think this really shifted was I went to my English teacher who was beloved and respected by our student body, uh, for some career advice. And I came out of this meeting, uh, 180 degrees different than what I expected going in. And in fact, she told me that, uh, I would never amount to anything in my life and that, uh, it was almost, uh, worthless for me to go to college, uh, because, uh, She didn't see much potential in me at all. So what that triggered in me. after spending so many years of my life trying to overcome what.
10:07 It happened to me when I was young. It really caused in me this feeling that I was not enough and that I really needed to achieve things to be seen in the world. And so that kind of pushed me, I think, over the edge to go to the Naval Academy and to take that route in life because it really caused me to feel that I had to perform if I was going to be seen by people like her. Oh, for a young kid to experience, I mean, as it is, you had been through so much trauma in your life and then to experience that, And that's why it's so important that, you know, our teachers need to be careful about the mental health perspective as well.
10:55 And that can be. Regardless anyone passing that judgment can break or make a person's life. So sorry you had to go through that. But it sounds like you turned it around. So tell us a little bit more about your career in. Military or naval. Yeah. Well, I had a, I had a fantastic, um, career. I did a number of tours in the military and was able to serve on everything from aircraft carriers, destroyers, cruisers, submarines. Um, I, I got to fly, I got to deploy with special forces units and, uh, it all culminated for me, um, where I had a position as the executive officer, um, in a detachment for the national security agency on the nation's counter drug, uh, inter agency task force, uh, which was an, a flag level, uh, joint command that I was part of. And as I was serving there, I was recruited by a number of three letter organizations, um, that were very much involved in counter narcotic, uh, and, That led me to accepting an appointment as a special agent for the FBI. So I got out of the military to accept that appointment when fate happened again. And
12:30 literally about 72 to 96 hours prior to me going to Quantico, Congress was unable to pass the funding bill. And so my class got reshuffled. And unfortunately, it wasn't a short reshuffling. it was about a 40 month reshuffling. So, uh, imagine yourself getting out of the military thinking that you had a strong plan a, and I didn't have a plan B because I didn't think I needed one after going through 18 months of interviews and everything else just to get into the FBI. So it, it caused a rear, another completely different path in my life. And I ended up, uh, Luckily, getting hired by Booz Allen, who if people are not familiar with Booz Allen, they're kind of a combination at that point in time between a strategy company like McKinsey or Bain Consulting and a government provider of services such as SAIC. And it was actually a phenomenal landing point for me. And from there, I transitioned to Arthur Andersen.
13:43 and then eventually into Fortune 500 companies such as Lowe's and Dell, and then eventually becoming a private equity partner and before launching what I'm doing now. So, John, you've had a very, very impressive career. What would you say were some of the common lessons that you learned from military and then experiencing the setback and then going into the fortune 50 leadership and fortune 500 leaderships that you can share with our audience because life happens. And so many times. Especially in today's era, like so many people are getting laid off and with AI and there's so much uncertainty all around that. What are some of the lessons that you could share and would tell people about not to lose their individuality and hold themselves together while thriving.
14:46 Coming out of the military, and especially my time at the Naval Academy, when I think back upon going there, I really think more than anything else that you learn there, it's really one of the finest leadership academies that you can go to in the world. I mean, we all come out with a bachelor's of science in engineering with a separate degree on top of it. But more so, I think they really teach you servant leadership. And so I went into the workforce after I got out of the military, really using service servant leadership as the primary way I led until I experienced, um, an event when I joined Lowe's that completely transformed how I think about leadership and what I think is necessary in today's world.
15:45 I was hired at Lowe's because in 2003, 2004, Lowe's suffered the worst hacking incident in retail history up until that point. In fact, the people who orchestrated this hacking incident were actually sentenced to jail. One of them got about a decade in prison. Another one got a little bit over two years. And I thought that would be the biggest thing that I had to deal with as I came into Lowe's. But very early into my tenure, like a week or two into it, can't believe they didn't tell me this before I was hired. I had a one-on-one with the chief human resources officer who was fairly new herself and told me, that she had just put forth the first employee engagement survey in Lowe's history.
16:40 And out of 350,000 team members, I had inherited the group that scored the lowest in the entire company. Oh. And as I accepted this group, what I discovered was as I talked to my peer group, and many of the executives whose functions we supported, I had very consistent feedback. You need to hire a new boss of people. Your group is completely broken. They don't care. They're not interested.
17:20 They're not invested. They're checked out. All those different things. But then I did. The thing that I think is so important. I went out and I talked to as many of the employees in the organization as I possibly could, which running a 24 by seven operation in many different locations meant that I would meet with people at two o'clock in the morning. I would go to the data centers. I would go to the distribution centers. I w I was trying to get a feel for collectively what was happening. And what I learned was that although we had given people in the organization a seat at the table, we hadn't really given them a voice at the table. And more so than that, they didn't realize in clear terms how the roles that they were performing impacted the greater strategy, customer satisfaction, shareholder value, of Lowe's in general. And then on top of that, no one had really taken the time to learn about them and to understand them from a personal level outside of their work role. Like what was happening personally in their life? What were their aspirations? What were
18:54 some of the things that were happening to them in their family situation? Maybe they had a sick parent that they were taking care of or were a coach outside of Lowe's hours, or maybe they had a passion like playing music. And so what I found fundamentally is that we had a mattering crisis going on in the group and that in order to solve this, I had to nurture the very, the very, environment that they were existing in, which really shifted my mentality that being a servant leader wasn't going to be enough. I needed to become a gardener leader where I could create the nutrients for them to feel significant, but also to not only have a seat at the table but to actually have a voice that influenced the direction around them.
19:57 Oh that's powerful and as you continue to nurture them and provide what they needed where they felt seen and valued What was the change that resulted? Well, I will never forget some of the conversations and the resulting behavior change that I saw. I remember sitting down with very experienced managers, managers and directors who had at that point decades under their belt. And I remember sitting in in our operations command center, uh, one evening, it was probably 11 or 12 o'clock at night. And I was having a one-on-one with, uh, one of the command center managers. And, and he, he was saying to me, John, um, what exactly do you, do you need me to do, um, to get this group to perform better? And I said to him, I can't be here at 24 by seven.
21:01 So I. What I can do for you is I can make it very clear what we're trying to achieve. I can give you tools to help bolster your leadership. But I need to be hands-off, very similar to a gardener raising crops, that if I give you the conditions to thrive, you're going to have to be the on-scene leader who understands what's happening in their group and is fortifying the people underneath you. And he looked at me and he said, in over 25 years, no one has given me the ability to use my leadership acumen the way that I think situationally should fit to lead a group. And I couldn't believe it. And what I learned from that is that you have to inherently trust the people who are working for you. If, if, if you want things to turn around. And when employees started to see him leading and that he had the ability to change directions, that he had autonomy and that the leadership above him believed in him, it carried forth to his employees. And I used him as an example to the rest of the organization of what I was looking for in leadership. And so I then invited him to get in front of the group with me to talk about the changes he
22:33 was making, how it was impacting his organization. And it then gave permission for the other leaders to do the same because they saw that even if he made mistakes, we weren't, we weren't, you know, we would treat those as learning experiences rather than, you know, looking at them as disaster or broken or things like that. So coming out of this, it really allowed the entire organization to have faith that the leadership was going to listen to them, listen to their concerns, and let them have autonomy in many ways over the choices that they were making. And long story short, two years later, when the same employee engagement survey was done, the group scored second-highest So a massive turnaround.
23:33 Yeah, no, that's so powerful. And what I'm hearing is that when people are given ownership along with autonomy to make decisions and move forward, people step in and people step up and you see the change. So as we are talking about this, you know, you talk about The great erasure effect. Can you expand on that? Yeah. Henry David Thoreau wrote two centuries ago that the massive men, massive people lead lives of quiet desperation. And he was describing a world where we could see the world around us.
24:17 This was in the 1800s. It was right at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. And I think our challenge today, and you set it up well in your introduction, is that the walls around us have become harder to see. We're more digitally connected than we've ever been, yet more and more people are increasingly uncertain about where they belong, what gives their life meaning, and whether their presence actually makes a difference. And this is what I call quiet disorientation. Because what's happening is we're living in environments today that value what we produce, but they're not valuing the person underneath them. And this has led me to the idea of we're living in a mattering market, meaning the systems and institutions of modern life have become very good at measuring what we produce, but are far less good at recognizing who we are. And when that happens to people around the world, what it's causing is more and more people to forget who they are underneath that performance, which is causing so many people to experience this feeling that they feel invisible. And that is what leads to the great erasure, which I feel is happening to hundreds of millions of people globally.
25:49 Yeah, no, very well said. John, you're absolutely on the mark with the fact that what happens is we are so focused on performance, performance, performance, and the output that the person behind it is lost. And especially as people are laid off, their identity is so attached with the jobs that they're doing. And even while they're in that job, like, oh, if I don't perform well, then where am I at? Well. Where do I belong? And what level am I at? Like, you know, so that identity tie-in is so devastating or alarming because it causes attacks. And you talk about the mattering tax. Tell us about the hidden costs that it brings along with it.
26:42 Yeah. One of the greatest impacts it brings is something that I call the slow fade. because this is what it felt like, what happened in me. And this slow fade is really this phenomenon that happens when repeated experience of being unseen, unheard, or unvalued make you slowly withdraw from your own life. You still function, you still succeed, but less and less of you is actually present. And what I learned from going through this is that that achievement that caused me to strive for success ultimately was measuring my output. But when you think about mattering, mattering is the felt sense that your life has value and that your presence and actions make a difference. But when that slow fade is happening, eventually it feels like you're wearing a pair of glasses that over time is starting to get smudges on them. But you, as you're living through this, you realize you don't feel as fulfilled as you did the day before. You don't feel as alive, but you kind of can't put your finger on it because the changes are happening so gradually. And yet you don't have
28:14 a piece of fabric that you can use to to remove the blemishes from the glasses. So it gets blurrier and blurrier and blurrier until you can't see out of the glasses anymore. And that's when the vanish happens. And that's exactly what happened to me. I felt like I was vanishing from my own life and the consequences are catastrophic because it infiltrates every aspect of your life. It, it causes you imagine you're living on a stool and underneath you, the things that stabilize that stool are your relationships, your physical health, your emotional health, your mental health. Et cetera, et cetera.
28:56 Well, mattering is like water. It cascades through every element of our life. And when you experience systemic unmattering, it impacts all of it. So your relationships start going down the tank, your physical health gets impacted, your emotional health, well-being gets impacted, your mental health gets impacted, our feeling of connection gets impacted. So ultimately, what this led me to is realizing that these things that we keep treating as separate epidemics, loneliness, hopelessness, people feeling burned out, employee disengagement, I feel are all symptoms of sustainability. unmattering. So those are the repercussions of this and why I think that this is impacting so many people globally.
29:51 Absolutely. And as we talk about people being quietly disappearing from their own lives, it's going to have impact all around. It's not only going to have impact on their productivity, their happiness, their relationships, their health. And as a result, it impacts everything associated with it, whether it is productivity. And then like for the organizations, that translates into profitability or enterprise value. So when we put all of these together, how can we address it? So I have a new book coming out called The Mattering Effect. And in it, I spend two or three chapters, a very small portion of the book, outlining the problem that you and I just went through. 70% of the.
30:41 Book is. All about how do you rebuild this in your life? And so a core framework that I have in the book is something called The Matter Compass. And when I think of the matter compass and I think of mattering, mattering is really the foundation of our lives. It's what meaning, connectingness, et cetera, sit upon. So I think of it as the human operating system. So in the matter compass framework, there are four dimensions. True north is what I refer to as personal mattering. And this is the first thing that in order to restore mattering, we need to work on.
31:25 It really gets into, do I matter to myself? And this is your baseline. The second quadrant is relational mattering or EAST. Do I matter to others in a way that actually reaches me? And this really gets to, is care flowing in both ways? Do I give value and do I get value in return? Or is it only going in one direction? And then that leads us to emotional mattering, which is the West quadrant. Does my inner life matter enough to be felt? And this is all about the courage to stop managing your feelings as liabilities and to start allowing actual experience to exist without immediate correction.
32:13 And then lastly, it involves impact mattering, which is the Southern quadrant. Do my choices change what happens next? And so. Looking at those four quadrants, it then has an overlay of the matter framework. And the matter framework consists of the conditions of meaning, autonomy, time, trust, energy, and reciprocity. And what I found through my research is when those conditions are present, Mattering flows like water should. But when any of those conditions becomes interrupted, it starts impacting our feeling of mattering. When all of that comes together, you experience the mattering dividend.
33:09 And of course, I'm sure you'll probably guess my next question when we are talking about the dividend. Yes, we talked about the hidden cause. Now you are bringing, and what a powerful question. framework with that compass and so much easy when you think about it right that is so part of our lives when we talk about the directions and all that so easy to relate to so as people will start putting the mentoring framework in their lives you talked about the dividends what are some of the benefits. Well i mean. They're enormous so So the first thing is it restores that very foundation that I talked about. So the most important idea that I learned studying this is that mattering starts and ends with yourself. And I think so many people today are not feeling that. So the first thing is it restores those components of the stool that I talked about.
34:16 It builds back. Your relationship health, your emotional health, mental health, et cetera. And it restores your social buffer, which are the connections that you have in your life. But the bigger thing that restoring this allows you to do is it puts forth the mattering effect, which is now that you are functioning as you are fully alive, it then allows you to reconnect with to the most vital relationships you have. And those are the relationships in your home, the relationships that you have with the intimate people in your life, whether that's friends, your partner, your family members. It extends into the work environments that we find ourselves in, the communities that surround our lives, and ultimately the impacts that we have on society as a whole.
35:12 Absolutely. And Here's the thing. If you invest in yourself and the framework is so powerful, easy to relate to, that it's going to keep on paying the dividends in all areas of life, John, as you summarized. And it's not only for now, but this is something when you invest in yourself, you are investing for life. It's something, the best investment, as they say at Not sure who said it, like most likely it was Warren Buffett. The best investment you can make is investing in yourself. And so this is fantastic. Thank you for sharing so openly with us, John. So if people wanted to connect with you, where can they find you?
36:00 There are three primary paths. I have a very active sub stack called the ignited life, which you can get to at the ignited life.net. If you're interested in catching what I have to say on a weekly basis, I have a podcast called Passion Struck, which you can go to at passionstruck.com. And lastly, you can learn about the new book at matteringeffect.com. It launches October 6th. Well, it's coming pretty soon. And I'm sure, wonderful audience, that our conversation today has definitely got your curiosity going and that you'll be looking out for John's book. So I'm definitely going to be looking out for it. And I invite you to look out for John's book as well. And as we bring our conversation to a close, are there any last minute thoughts you'd like to share with our audience, John?
37:00 One of the core concepts that I really talk about in the book came to me from William James' research. And that is so many of us today are functioning as resources to everyone else, and it's depleting us. So a core thing that I would like people to know is this idea of becoming a source. And when you become a source, that's when the mattering dividend really takes root because you become a source to others. And by doing that, you get that reciprocated back to you. So they become a source to you. And that's one of the most important evolutions when the impact that you're making becomes profound and you change the whole way that you're viewed in the world. So that is something I'd like to end with.
38:06 Yeah, no, definitely. That is powerful. And it's important. Know that you matter. You are here for a purpose. And when your cup is full, you can help others even more. So thank you, John, for joining us and sharing your wisdom with us. And I'm sure our audience is going to walk away with A lot of nuggets. I know I got quite a few nuggets myself. And thank you, wonderful audience, for being part of our family because without your love and support and sharing with us, this show would not be possible. And we are here to help you live the best life you can and the life you deserve. So please reach out to us like you always do and let us know how we can serve and support you in Thank you, Juan, for being a tech genius. And thank you, everyone. Be well and take care until next time.
39:08 Thank you for being part of Beyond Confidence with your host, Divya Park. We hope you have learned more about how to start living the life you want. Each week on Beyond Confidence, you hear stories of real people who have experienced growth by overcoming their fears and building meaningful relationships. During Beyond Confidence, Divya Park shares what happened to her when she stepped out of her comfort zone to work directly with people. across the globe. She not only coaches people how to form heart connections, but also transform relationships to mutually beneficial partnerships as they strive to live the life they want. If you are ready to live the life you want and leverage your strengths, learn more at www.diviapark.com and you can connect with Divya at contact at divyapark.com.
39:52 We look forward to you joining us next week.